Can a Torn Mensicus Heal without Surgery?

Josh in NSW Australia asks:

"I have torn my meniscus. Is there any way that this can heal without having surgery?"

Marc Bernier and Douglas Palma, at the Alabama Sports Medicine and Orthopaedic Center (ASMOC), reply:

"As recently as 1970, the meniscus was thought to be a vestigial structure with little function. However, our knowledge has since expanded and we now realize their importance in the normal function of the knee. The functions of the meniscus include load bearing, shock absorption, and joint stabilization, all of which are vital characteristics in preventing deterioration of the joint, which is very vulnerable in the sport of soccer due to the nature of the game (extensive cutting, pivoting, etc).

"The meniscus is composed of two semilunar fibrocartilaginous disks that are found between the distal femoral condyles and tibial plateau. They both are approximately c-shaped with a thick peripheral rim that taper to a thin inner edge, which in cross section appear as a triangle. Each one has a distinct shape and features. The medial meniscus is semicircular, approximately 3.5 cm in length, and is wider posteriorly than anteriorly. It has an average excursion on flexion and extension of the knee of 5mm, which is less than the lateral meniscus. It is also continuously attached to the joint capsule and at its midpoint to the deep medial collateral ligament. The lateral meniscus is circular and covers a larger portion of the tibial plateau than the medial meniscus. It has loose peripheral attachments to the joint capsule and an average excursion of approximately 11mm during flexion-extension movements of the knee.

"The annual incidence of injury to the meniscus ranges from 60 to 70 per 100,000, with an estimated 850,000 meniscal procedures performed each year. There has been found a male-to female ratio of approximately 2.5-4 to 1. Higher incidences of meniscal injuries have been found with anterior cruciate ligament injuries (lateral meniscus more commonly affected) and tibial plateau fractures.

"A thorough history and physical are essential to diagnosis. Most injuries are sustained from a twisting injury with the knee flexed and the foot planted on the ground. A pop could have been felt but is not always the case. A history of catching, locking, or popping may aid in the diagnosis of a meniscal tear. On physical exam, joint line tenderness and provocative testing (i.e. McMurray or Apley tests) are essential to confirm the pathology. MRI can be confirmatory, but is not 100% sensitive or specific.

"Once the diagnosis has been made and confirmed, a treatment plan can be implemented. The decision must be made to either perform an excision of the torn fragment of the meniscus (partial menisectomy), or perform a repair of the tear. Many years ago, total menisectomies were the treatment of choice; however, it has since been found that removal of the entire meniscus resulted in a 200% increase in contact pressure within the joint. As a result, the technique of performing partial menisectomies was developed.

"Initial research indicates that even with partial menisectomies, contact pressures increase by approximately 65%. This has lead to attempts at repairing meniscal tears, in which the "loose ends" of the tear are sutured or anchored together, and allowing healing to occur similar to that seen in skin lacerations. Unfortunately, research indicates that a small minority of all meniscus tears are amenable to repair.

"Tears that occur in the vascular zone of the meniscus ("red-red" zone, outer 20-30%) have the greatest potential to heal, while tears at the vascular boundary ("red-white" zone) have somewhat less healing potential. Tears located entirely within the avascular zone ("white-white" zone) have limited potential to heal; nutrients are supplied by the synovial fluid. However, some physicians have advocated repairs of meniscal tears in this avascular region, with reports of acceptable success rates.

"Other determining factors in the ability to repair meniscal tears include the size, type and location of the tear, degree of degeneration within the joint, and complexity of the tear. If the characteristics of the tear are not conducive to repair, partial menisectomy is the next treatment option in the soccer athlete.

"Rehabilitation in the post-operative phase and return to play differ depending on the surgical procedure performed. In the case of partial menisectomies, weight bearing is allowed to tolerance, with an accelerated progression to closed kinetic chain and proprioceptive exercises. Typically, the rate of progression is dependent upon pain and effusion, with a usual return to play in 4-6 weeks. If a meniscal repair is performed, a much slower program is followed, with a more restricted weight bearing gait pattern that is gradually increased. Progression to closed chain activities occurs more slowly, with a goal of a return to play in 5-6 months.

More about Marc Bernier >

Thanks to Dr Douglas Palma MD for his help in compiling this article.

Article published: 11th July 2003




Row View Grid View

Donjoy Strapping Elastic Knitted Knee Brace

£34.99 inc VAT

The Donjoy Strapping Elastic Knee Brace has been designed to improve knee stability and ease the related symptoms of mild osteoarthritis. Created primarily for sports use the Donjoy is ideally suited following acute and chronic knee conditions although it can be utilised for day-to-day living.
More Details

Availability: In Stock

Quantity

Vulkan 5mm Neoprene Knee Support (open kneecap)

£21.99 inc VAT

Great for relieving knee pain in cold weather and features an open kneecap section to provide mild support to relieve knee pain and swelling without pressuring the knee cap.
More Details

Vulkan 5mm Neoprene Knee Support (open kneecap) has a rating of 5.0 stars from 6 reviews (6 reviews)

Availability: In Stock

Quantity

Donjoy TROM Advance Cool

119.99 inc VAT Was 125.99 Save 6.00 (5%)

State-of-the-art hinged knee brace for rehab following knee surgery.
More Details

Donjoy TROM Advance Cool has a rating of 5.0 stars from 1 reviews (1 review)

Availability: Delivered within 3 to 5 working days.

Quantity

Donjoy Sports Hinged Knee Wrap

£49.99 inc VAT

The Donjoy Sports Hinged Knee Wrap has been designed to support mild to moderate collateral ligament injuries with removable polycentric aluminium stays to assist the medial (inner) and lateral (outer) aspect of the knee.
More Details

Availability: Delivered within 3 to 5 working days.

Quantity

Donjoy Reddie Brace

£29.99 inc VAT

The Donjoy Reddie Knee Brace has been designed specifically for the older patient with unique application features to assist in quick and easy fitting.
More Details

Availability: Delivered within 3 to 5 working days.

Quantity

Donjoy X-ACT Knee

£119.99 inc VAT

The X-Act ROM Knee is the lightest post-surgery brace currently manufactured by Donjoy and takes comfort, fit and functionality to the next level.
More Details

Availability: Delivered within 3 to 5 working days.

Quantity

BodyHelix Full Knee SS Support Silver

£44.99 inc VAT

The BodyHelix Full Knee Helix in GB Silver is the chosen support of 1966 England World Cup Winner Gordon Banks. The former goalkeeper maintains a healthy lifestyle and although Gordon doesn't suffer from any specific ailments the BodyHelix sleeve helps to support age-related nagging aches and pains.
More Details

BodyHelix Full Knee SS Support Silver has a rating of 5.0 stars from 2 reviews (2 reviews)

Availability: In Stock

Quantity

BodyHelix Full Knee SS Black

£44.99 inc VAT

This Black Full Knee support has been designed using patented BodyHelix SuperStretch™ material to help create an extremely comfortable, lightweight pull-on sleeve which will not slip or nip the skin.
More Details

Availability: In Stock

Quantity

medi Collamed Knee Brace

£259.99 inc VAT


More Details

Availability: In Stock

Quantity

medi M4s Knee Brace

£499.99 inc VAT


More Details

Availability: In Stock

Quantity

medi PT Control

£189.99 inc VAT


More Details

Availability: In Stock

Quantity

Physicool Cooling Bandage (10cm x 2m) - Ideal for wrists, ankles, elbows

£9.99 inc VAT

Physicool is an innovative and uniquely designed reusable strapping that combines the healing characteristics of cold therapy with the support qualities of a compression bandage. Differing from the more traditional treatments currently available, Physicool works by drawing heat away from the body to provide an instant long-lasting cooling effect which can be utilised for extended periods.
More Details

Physicool Cooling Bandage (10cm x 2m) - Ideal for wrists, ankles, elbows has a rating of 5.0 stars from 2 reviews (2 reviews)

Availability: In Stock

Quantity

Physicool Combination Pack

£14.99 inc VAT

The Physicool combination pack supplies you with one specially formulated cooling bandage and one bottle of recharging coolant which will rejuvenate and refresh the dressing. Small and compact this kit is ideal for wrist, elbow and ankle injuries providing between 2-3 hours of cold therapy and compression.
More Details

Physicool Combination Pack has a rating of 5.0 stars from 2 reviews (2 reviews)

Availability: In Stock

Quantity

Physicool Cooling Bandage (12cm x 3m) - Ideal for knees, legs, shoulders, back

£12.99 inc VAT

Physicool is a new and unique way to instantly apply cold therapy whilst on the move, this portable and reusable compression bandage is applied quickly and easily allowing the healing process to begin immediately. By taking heat away from the body Pysicool have developed a product which differs from move traditional methods meaning it can be used for longer periods.
More Details

Physicool Cooling Bandage (12cm x 3m) - Ideal for knees, legs, shoulders, back has a rating of 5.0 stars from 3 reviews (3 reviews)

Availability: In Stock

Quantity

Hyperice Knee Support

71.99 inc VAT Was 74.99 Save 3.00 (4%)

The Hyperice cold therapy system is an innovative application device created to ensure optimal ice treatment on the move, sub-zero compression without limitation.
More Details

Availability: In Stock

Quantity

PhysioRoom.com Resistance Exercise Band

3.49 inc VAT Was 5.49 Save 2.00 (36%)

Latex Bands provide light, medium to heavy resistance during training exercises and are designed for increasing strengthening exercises during rehab and sports training. 99.99% free from latex allergens.
More Details

PhysioRoom.com Resistance Exercise Band has a rating of 5.0 stars from 1 reviews (1 review)

Availability: In Stock

Quantity

PhysioRoom.com Water Floatation Belt

19.99 inc VAT Was 39.99 Save 20.00 (50%)

The Water Floatation Belt is ideal for early non weight bearing cardiovascular training as its design allows the user to run in the pool without putting stress through their injury. It is perfect following injuries such as fractures and stress fractures, knee ligament injuries, sprained ankle or swollen ankle, as well as following knee surgery and ankle surgery once the wounds are sufficiently healed.
More Details

PhysioRoom.com Water Floatation Belt has a rating of 5.0 stars from 1 reviews (1 review)

Availability: In Stock

Quantity

PhysioRoom.com Resistance Band Exercise Loop

£2.49 inc VAT

These multi-coloured tubes provide four levels of resistance, ideal for progressing strengthening exercises.
More Details

PhysioRoom.com Resistance Band Exercise Loop has a rating of 5.0 stars from 3 reviews (3 reviews)

Availability: Selected options in stock

Quantity

PhysioRoom.com Exercise Band Loop (medium) - Pack of 5

6.99 inc VAT Was 14.99 Save 8.00 (53%)

These red coloured tubes provide medium resistance, ideal for progressing strengthening exercises.
More Details

PhysioRoom.com Exercise Band Loop (medium) - Pack of 5 has a rating of 5.0 stars from 1 reviews (1 review)

Availability: In Stock

Quantity

PhysioRoom.com Foam Rehab Water Aid Swimming Noodle

3.99 inc VAT Was 7.99 Save 4.00 (50%)

Made from buoyant, lightweight foam the Foam Water Noodle is ideal for use as a floating and buoyancy device and is suitable for rehabilitation exercises. The Water Noodle is very durable and is extremely resistant to water absorption and swimming pool chemicals.
More Details

Availability: Selected options in stock

Quantity

PhysioRoom.com 5.5m x15cm Resistance Band Box - Choose between 5 Levels

7.99 inc VAT Was 14.99 Save 7.00 (47%)

Latex Bands provide light, medium to heavy resistance during training exercises and are designed for increasing strengthening exercises during rehab and sports training.
More Details

PhysioRoom.com 5.5m x15cm Resistance Band Box - Choose between 5 Levels has a rating of 5.0 stars from 5 reviews (5 reviews)

Availability: Selected options in stock

Quantity

PhysioRoom.com Ankle and Wrist Weights X2 1 Pound

£11.99 inc VAT

The PhysioRoom.com Ankle and Wrist Weights each weigh one pound and feature a soft, terrycloth fabric on the inside to ensure a very comfortable fit.
More Details

PhysioRoom.com Ankle and Wrist Weights X2 1 Pound has a rating of 5.0 stars from 1 reviews (1 review)

Availability: In Stock

Quantity

PhysioRoom.com Plastic Speed Skipping Rope With Foam Handles

2.99 inc VAT Was 9.99 Save 7.00 (70%)

The speed skipping rope features ergonomically shaped foam handles which provide a very comfortable grip while skipping.
More Details

Availability: In Stock

Quantity

PhysioRoom.com Elite Water Swimming Aid Noodles x3 (Red, Green and Blue)

9.99 inc VAT Was 14.99 Save 5.00 (33%)

The Elite water swimming aid noodles are made from lightweight, buoyant foam and are ideal for using as floating and buoyancy devices. The water noodles are also ideal for rehabilitation exercises.
More Details

Availability: Out Of Stock (Due 03-10-2014)

More Details

PhysioRoom.com Elite Water Swimming Aid Noodles x6 (Red x2, Green x2 and Blue x2)

19.99 inc VAT Was 24.99 Save 5.00 (20%)

The pack of six swimming aid noodles feature a variety of colours including x2 red, x2 green and x2 blue and are made from buoyant and lightweight foam.
More Details

Availability: Out Of Stock (Due 03-10-2014)

More Details

PhysioRoom.com Elite Water Swimming Aid Noodles x9 (Red x3, Green x3 and Blue x3)

29.99 inc VAT Was 39.99 Save 10.00 (25%)

The water noodles can be used as floating and buoyancy aids and are also ideal for rehab and therapy exercises.
More Details

Availability: Out Of Stock (Due 03-10-2014)

More Details

PhysioRoom.com Elite Water Swimming Aid Noodles x18 (Red x6, Green x 6 and Blue x6)

59.99 inc VAT Was 74.99 Save 15.00 (20%)

The foam water noodles are ideal for rehabilitation and therapy exercises and also great for kids to use too.
More Details

Availability: Out Of Stock (Due 03-10-2014)

More Details

PhysioRoom.com Elite Aqua Rehab Pack - Aquabelt, Ankle and Wrist Weights and x3 Water Noodles

34.99 inc VAT Was 59.99 Save 25.00 (42%)

The Aqua Rehab Pack contains everything you require for rehab and general exercises in the swimming pool. The Aqua Rehab Pack includes an aquabelt, ankle and wrist weights and three water noodles.
More Details

Availability: Out Of Stock (Due 03-10-2014)

More Details

PhysioRoom.com 5.5mx15cm Resistance Bands All Strengths 5 Boxes 5 Levels Of Resistance

39.99 inc VAT Was 59.99 Save 20.00 (33%)

This resistance exercise band pack features five boxes each of which has varying levels of resistance. Each latex band measures 5.5mx15cm and can be cut accordingly to suit your preference. Latex bands provide light, medium to heavy resistance during exercise and are specifically designed to increase strength during rehab and sports training.
More Details

PhysioRoom.com 5.5mx15cm Resistance Bands All Strengths 5 Boxes 5 Levels Of Resistance has a rating of 5.0 stars from 1 reviews (1 review)

Availability: Out Of Stock (Due 03-10-2014)

More Details

McDavid Adjustable Patella Knee Support

49.95 inc VAT Was 57.95 Save 8.00 (14%)

'One Size Fits All' knee support for knee ligament and cartilage injuries. The wraparound neoprene design has supportive steel springs to provide good support.
More Details

Availability: In Stock

Quantity

Mueller Pro Style Hinged Knee Brace (deluxe)

64.99 inc VAT Was 74.99 Save 10.00 (13%)

The patented Tri-Axial adjustable hinges provide excellent protection for skiing and sports. Ideal for prevention and rehabilitation of ACL and other knee ligament injuries.
More Details

Mueller Pro Style Hinged Knee Brace (deluxe) has a rating of 3.0 stars from 2 reviews (2 reviews)

Availability: Selected options in stock

Quantity

Aircast Knee Cryo/Cuff

59.99 inc VAT Was 79.99 Save 20.00 (25%)

Knee Cryo/Cuff™ for use with Aircast Cooler to relieve knee pain and swelling.
More Details

Availability: In Stock

Quantity

PhysioRoom.com Instant Ice Pack

From £0.49 inc VAT     1+ £2.03 each
    6+ £1.49 each (Save 27%)
  12+ £0.99 each (Save 51%)
  24+ £0.69 each (Save 66%)
  50+ £0.49 each (Save 76%)

A mouldable pack that becomes an instant, single use ice pack, without the need for refrigeration.
More Details

PhysioRoom.com Instant Ice Pack has a rating of 5.0 stars from 5 reviews (5 reviews)

Availability: In Stock

Quantity

Mueller Hg80 Knee Brace with Kevlar

49.99 inc VAT Was 62.99 Save 13.00 (21%)

Mueller Hg80 Knee Brace with Kevlar. Ultra comfortable hinge free knee brace with closed kneecap. Features flexible steel springs that provide support for cartilage injuries, mild arthritis and collateral knee ligament injuries.
More Details

Mueller Hg80 Knee Brace with Kevlar has a rating of 5.0 stars from 15 reviews (15 reviews)

Availability: In Stock

Quantity

Donjoy Drytex Playmaker Knee Brace

169.99 inc VAT Was 188.99 Save 19.00 (10%)

Superb sports and skiing hinged knee brace for ACL knee ligament injuries and cartilage tears. Has hi tech hinge system that can be locked at 9 different ranges of knee bend.
More Details

Availability: In Stock

Quantity
FREE Next Day Delivery

Aircast Knee Cryo/Cuff with Cooler

107.99 inc VAT Was 146.99 Save 39.00 (27%)

Ultimate knee ice therapy. Provides 6 hours continuous cold and compression to minimise bleeding, swelling and pain.
More Details

Aircast Knee Cryo/Cuff with Cooler has a rating of 5.0 stars from 16 reviews (16 reviews)

Availability: In Stock

Knee Cryo/Cuff Quantity
FREE Next Day Delivery

Row View Grid View


Related Articles