Medial Knee Ligament Tear

William in Belfast, Northern Ireland asks:

"I've torn my medial ligament and stretched my anterior cruciate ligament on the inner part of my knee. I was wondering if I will tear my cruciate now that I have stretched it?"

Dr Christopher Piller, MD, Orthopedic Fellow, American Sports Medicine Institute and Dr Lawrence Lemak, MD reply:

"The diagnosis of a 'stretched' or partially torn anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) is controversial. This diagnosis is difficult to make accurately based solely on physical exam findings or an MRI scan. Increased knee laxity with a soft endpoint found in an ACL on manual testing after an injury almost universally means a complete tear. Increased laxity with a solid endpoint (the so called 'stretched' ACL) can be due to a portion of the fibers being torn while some remain intact, or result from a complete tear that has managed to scar down or heal in such a way that it can still provide some stability in preventing abnormal forward movement of the tibia (shin bone).

"Many surgeons base the diagnosis of a partial ACL tear on the findings at arthroscopy, and the incidence in published studies ranges from 10 to 50% of all ACL injuries. The incidence is most likely closer to 10% if all diagnostic tools are utilized, including consideration of injury mechanism and concurrent injuries, objective manual laxity testing, MRI results, examination under anesthesia and arthroscopic findings. An exam under anesthesia, demonstrating abnormal pivoting (where the knee joint virtually subluxes due to instability), and anterior translation of a knee, is probably the single most accurate way to distinguish a partial tear from a complete tear.

"Injuries to the medial collateral ligament (MCL) occur in approximately 20% of all ACL injuries. Initially, depending upon the severity of the injury to the MCL, the knee will be more prone to instability than if the ACL was torn by itself. However, with proper rehabilitation and management, even completely torn MCLs have been shown to heal well without surgery and should not affect the long term stability and functional abilities.

"That being said, there are few studies that tried to predict the risk of residual instability and further knee injury with a half torn ACL found at arthroscopy. One study found a 50% incidence of instability and a 75% incidence of further knee injuries with a partial tear. Another study, however, demonstrated a very low incidence of instability, limitations with sports or work activities, or the development of arthritis. Out of 21 patients, none went on to require ACL reconstructive surgery. This discrepancy is most likely due to a difference in the demands and expectations of the patients studied.

"Although it is very difficult to predict the likelihood of completely rupturing your partially torn ACL, general guidelines have been established for addressing a situation such as yours. For the person who has sustained a true partial ACL tear, treatment must be customized. If the tear is estimated at greater than 50% of the ligament fibres; if there are symptoms of instability present (buckling or 'giving way' of the knee); or the patient is in a high-risk or high demand category (athlete, manual laborer) then early ACL reconstruction should be considered to prevent later problems of re-injury or arthritis. Patients with a tear less than 50% of ligament fibres, or patients with a sedentary lifestyle and no symptoms of instability, can be treated conservatively. Of this group, perhaps 10% of patients may later go on to require ligament reconstruction due to re-injury or onset of instability."

Recommended Products for MCL Knee Ligament Injury

MCL Knee Braces & Supports

Vulkan 5mm Neoprene Knee Support (open kneecap)

Our Price
£19.99

Great for relieving knee pain in cold weather and features an open kneecap section to provide mild support to relieve knee pain...

More Details

FREE Vulkan Bottle with this item on orders > £50

Mueller Hinged Wraparound Knee Brace (extra lite)

Our Price
£49.99 £41.99

Superb value wraparound design knee brace with metal hinges and adjustable Velcro straps for a custom fit. Protects the knee...

More Details

Be seen at night!
£FREE Reflective Snap Band

FREE Drinks Bottle with this item on orders > £50

Mueller Pro Style Hinged Knee Brace (deluxe)

Our Price
£69.99

The patented Tri-Axial adjustable hinges provide excellent protection for skiing and sports. Ideal for prevention and...

More Details

Be seen at night!
£FREE Reflective Snap Band

FREE Drinks Bottle with this item on orders > £50

---

Vulkan Silicon Knee Support

Our Price
£29.99 £21.99

Silicon lined knee support for knee injury treatment and sports use. Provides warmth and extra compression to speed up healing...

More Details

FREE Vulkan Bottle with this item on orders > £50

McDavid Adjustable Patella Knee Support

Our Price
£39.99 £34.99

'One Size Fits All' knee support for knee ligament and cartilage injuries. The wraparound neoprene design has supportive steel...

More Details

Donjoy Drytex Playmaker Knee Brace

Our Price
£174.99

ACL KNEE BRACESuperb sports and skiing hinged knee brace for ACL knee ligament injuries and cartilage tears. Has...

More Details

---

Top of Page

Ice Packs & Compression

PhysioRoom.com Instant Ice Pack

Our Price

  1+ £1.99
  6+ £1.49
12+ £0.99
24+ £0.50

SAVE UP TO 75%!A mouldable pack that becomes an instant ice pack, without the need for refrigeration. ...

More Details

Be seen at night!
£FREE Reflective Snap Band

Bodymedics Compression Cold Therapy Wrap (Knee)

Our Price
£49.99

NEW!Great value, superbly comfortable fabric ice pack and compression support for knee pain treatment....

More Details

Aircast Knee Cryo/Cuff (Self Contained)

Our Price
£69.99

NEW!Specialist knee ice therapy device. Fill it with ice and water to...
 (1 review)

More Details

---

PhysioRoom.com Sprains & Strains Repair Kit

Our Price
£14.91 £9.96

Essential ice and compression kit to relieve pain, reduce swelling and speed up recovery following a sports injury, muscle...

More Details

Be seen at night!
£FREE Reflective Snap Band

Mueller Reusable Cold/Hot Therapy Wrap (Large)

Our Price
£29.99 £25.99

Durable fabric wrap complete with one 15cm x 22.5cm (6" x 9") reusable Hot/Cold pack. Ideal for shoulder, knee, back, thigh,...

More Details

Be seen at night!
£FREE Reflective Snap Band

FREE Drinks Bottle with this item on orders > £50

Aircast Knee Cryo/Cuff with Cooler

Our Price
£139.99 £99.99

Ultimate knee ice therapy. Provides 6 hours continuous cold and compression to minimise bleeding,...
 (2 reviews)

More Details

---

Top of Page

Rehabilitation Kit

Exercise Band Pack

Our Price
£12.99

Superb value, 8 x 1m length resistance bands in all 4 varying strengths, for use during rehab exercises for the shoulder, ankle,...

More Details

 

AquaJogger 100 Floatation Belt

Our Price
£39.99 £26.99

The AquaJogger 100 is a floatation belt. One particular benefit is that it allows an early return...
 (1 review)

More Details

---

Top of Page

Related Articles

Injury A to Z: Medial Collateral Ligament Sprain >

• Home
• Injury Experts
• Ask the Experts

Related Articles

• Dr Donald Shelbourne: Update on ACL Rehab
• Injury A - Z: ACL Injuries Explained

© Copyright PhysioRoom.com 2001-2009. All rights reserved. Sitemap.

IMPORTANT SAFETY NOTICE
The articles on this web site are provided for general information only and should not be used as a basis for diagnosis or treatment. All exercises and information featured on this web site should only be practised under the supervision of a qualified healthcare professional.

We accept the following payment methods

PhysioRoom.com Limited, Unit 1 & 2 Dawson Court, Billington Road, Burnley, Lancashire BB11 5UB, England

Sports Injury & Physiotherapy Search Marketing by Epiphany.